Yale Daily News

Updated: Thursday, January 8, 2009 at 1:11am

The News will resume publication on January 12, 2009.

In China, Yale team wins CCTV debate competition

Favored to prevail, Yale’s team beats Oxford in final round contest for non-native Chinese speakers

  • Print
  • Write Editor
Staff Reporter
Published Monday, December 3, 2007
Yale’s Chinese debate team defeated delegations from universities around the world to claim victory in last week’s International Varsity Debate series, jointly hosted by New Media Singapore and China Central Television. The team — composed of Adam Scharfman ’08, Nick Sedlet ’08, Austin Woerner ’08 and J.T. Kennedy ’09 — beat students from Oxford University in the final round of the debate competition in Beijing to win the championship last Tuesday.
#1 By (Anonymous) 8:38am on December 3, 2007

The victory proves that Yale's model of Chinese language instruction is better than peer universities' in the world. Yale emphasizes on listening and speaking and teaching only simplified characters in 1st and 2nd year Chinese courses. Because we do not have to spend time learning both simplified and traditional/complex characters in these courses, we are able to practice spoken Chinese more. What we can learn from this victory is that we should not blindly follow other universities' models. We should continue to learn only simplified characters in the first and second year courses and learn complex characters in third and fourth year Chinese. The victory of the debate team showcases our exemplary model of instruction to other universities.

#2 By (Anonymous) 5:13pm on December 3, 2007

The victory proves that Yale has the best Chinese program in the world. Period.

Sedlet, Woerner, Scharfman, Kennedy have become models for the Chinese department, the Light Fellowship, and anyone involved in strengthening Yale-China relations.

Yale beat out the rest of the world, and each member of the debate team started Chinese 115 at Yale in 2004!

Let us not let the "simplified/traditional character debate" take away from this joyous news. Go Yale!!!

#3 By (Anonymous) 5:15pm on December 3, 2007

I agree, Yale's CCTV debate victory should not be used as ammunition in the simplified-traditional character debate!

#4 By (Anonymous) 5:51pm on December 3, 2007

GO YALE (and go Branford!!!) - this is a really great moment for the University and Im glad to see some exciting AND good news in the YDN this week!

#5 By (Anonymous) 8:40pm on December 3, 2007

from someone outside of the Yale community - you can all be proud of the scholarship and hard work that this victory entailed...may the skills be used to promote cultural understanding and wisdom between the diverse cultures. This language skill is so important for peaceful bridge building. This is potentially bigger than which university won and raises the big questions about how to make the best use of these skills and gifts. thank you.

#6 By (Anonymous) 1:13pm on December 6, 2007

"The victory proves that Yale has the best Chinese program in the world. Period."

'Best' in what respect? No quotes from 'hongloumeng' please ^^

#7 By Noah G. 10:47pm on December 21, 2007

Why didn't any of the national news media pick this up in the U.S.? Since Yale competed to represent the United States, this should be seen as a victory for the "national team" in some ways.

Add Comment

You are not logged in. We do allow posting without registration, but we encourage you to register or log in to enjoy full access to our comments features!